Building a Retro Game Collection - Where to Buy, Spot Fakes & Collector Tips

Starting a retro game collection is exciting but can be overwhelming. This guide helps you build a collection you'll love without breaking the bank or falling for common pitfalls.

Define Your Focus

Trying to collect everything is expensive and impractical. Consider focusing on:

• A single console: Master one library before expanding
• A genre: RPGs, platformers, shmups, fighters
• A series: All Mario games, complete Mega Man, etc.
• An era: 8-bit, 16-bit, or early 3D
• Games you'll actually play: The most practical approach

Where to Buy

Best Options

• Local game stores: Can inspect before buying, support local business
• Garage sales & flea markets: Best prices, but inconsistent
• Estate sales: Often untouched collections at fair prices
• Facebook Marketplace: Local pickup, negotiable prices

Online Options

• eBay: Largest selection, but prices are high. Use "sold listings" for price research.
• Mercari: Often better prices than eBay
• GameGavel: Auction site focused on games
• PriceCharting.com: Essential for checking fair market values

Spotting Fakes and Reproductions

Counterfeit cartridges are common, especially for expensive games. Warning signs:

• Price too good to be true
• Label quality differences (glossy vs. matte, color saturation)
• Wrong screw type (authentic Nintendo uses security screws)
• Seller has multiple copies of rare games
• Board doesn't match what's expected (open and inspect when possible)

Condition Matters

• Loose: Just the cartridge. Cheapest option, fine for playing.
• Complete in Box (CIB): Game, box, and manual. 2-5x loose price.
• New/Sealed: Investment territory. Prices can be astronomical.

For playing, loose is fine. For display, CIB is ideal. Sealed games are for serious collectors only.

Storage and Care

• Keep games away from direct sunlight (fades labels)
• Control humidity to prevent mold and corrosion
• Store cartridges vertically like books
• Use protective cases for loose games
• Clean contacts with isopropyl alcohol (90%+), never blow on them

Budget Strategies

Start with Common Games

Many excellent games are affordable: Super Mario Bros. 3 ($15-20), Zelda: A Link to the Past ($25-30), Sonic 2 ($10). Build a great library before chasing rarities.

Buy Lots

Bundles often have lower per-game prices. Sell duplicates to fund more purchases.

Be Patient

Prices fluctuate. Set alerts on eBay. Wait for deals rather than paying full price immediately.

Consider Japanese Versions

Japanese games are often much cheaper. Many platformers and action games need no translation.

Red Flags to Avoid

• Graded games (WATA/VGA) - inflated prices, questionable practices
• Paying premium for "rare" commons
• Buying cleaned/refurbished as original
• Rushing purchases without price research

Enjoy the Journey

Collecting should be fun. Play your games—they're meant to be enjoyed, not just displayed. The hunt is part of the hobby. Take your time and build a collection that means something to you.